Client Reviews

Joshua A. Brokas | Seller

The personal touch that Molly and Katie Penny provide is unparalleled. We had a challenging home buying process in which they fought to keep us in the game and eventually purchase our dream home. They are well rooted in the Mercer Island community, and I would recommend them to anyone looking to buyor sell their home. Molly and Katie know their business, and care very much about what they do.

William M. Merritt | Buyer

Molly and Katie are superstars. This is our second house working with. They are real pros with the personal touch. They care a lot about doing the right thing for their customers and the overall community. We cannot recommend them more highly!

Michael Fink | Seller

Very personal and responsive service.

Univ. of Idaho Foundation | Buyer

Very easy to work with, very responsive and helped put together a process that made the most of multiple offers.

Carrie Bell | Buyer

Katie and Molly Penny went out of their way to review our property and to educate us on the proper selling price. Katie was the key for us to prepare and stage our home for sale. Katie rolled up her sleeves and moved furniture, dusted surfaces and provided her own towels, shower curtains and flower vases. The fresh flowers really enhanced our home presentation.

Peter Van Oppen | Buyer

Compelling energy and commitment were brought to every phase of a hurried and difficult process. Thank you.

Ryan Wilson | Buyer

Market analysis, honest feedback, realistic expectation, and all the communication!!

Margaret Chon | Buyer

The realtors at CBB Mercer Island are very connected to other realtors, and they have an extensive network. This trust factor between agents is extremely helpful in facilitating successful transactions. There is a lot of expertise in the office about the local market and local agents. Molly broughtan extraordinarily high level of experience to this deal, and there is a warm personal touch to everything she does. Her interpersonal skills helped through some of the more perplexing interactions with the buyer. Thank you, Molly, and also Molly's co-agent Katie.

Spoul Family Rev Trust | Seller

Katie Penny Shea gave me a heads up about a condo that was coming on the market and I can't thank her enough. We are happy we bought it.

Jordan Hom | Seller

Molly and Katie were very professional, easy to work with, and went out of their ways to help me find a great place to live. They were both easily accessible through email, phone and text. They proactively followed up with both me and the Sellers regarding open or pending items. Additionally, they took time to explain the purchase process, as I am a first time homeowner.

Chris Strand | Buyer

I like the TEAM of MOLLY and her daughter. It is nice to have someone mature and someone young. It helped not only me dealing with them, but with potential buyers. Each generation speaks and acts differently, and with the two of them, it's great.

Arvid Hokanson | Seller

Experience, personal attention, accessibility of agents, wealth of knowledge about Island, connections to off-market opportunities.

John C. McAlvay | Buyer

I like Katie's ability to do everything necessary to get us the help we needed to prepare our home for sale, and her responsiveness to our concerns. Molly and Katie are a great team and Katie was more involved in our transaction than Molly was. They had different things to contribute to making our sale go quickly.

Beverly J. Harris | Buyer

They were prompt, interested, knowledgeable and very helpful. I enjoyed working with Molly Penny and her daughter, Katie.

David Kern | Seller

Molly and Katie are the best! They went above and beyond in guiding our home search. They understood the needs of a family relocating from another state and provided a level of support that inspired trust and confidence in their knowledge and expertise.

Gogulski Family Trust | Buyer

It was the realtors we worked with — specifically, Molly Penny and Katie Penny Shea — who were understanding and compassionate of our situation — selling our family home. We appreciated their knowledge to increase the value of the property and maximize the asking price which we were able to get. It felt like they went the extra mile for us

Walter Parietti | Buyer

The personal interest in the client - keeping us abreast of what is happening.

Stuart Harris | Buyer

Molly & Katie were both extremely responsive and did a great job walking us through the process of our first home sale. The staging service that they supplied was invaluable, as were their recommendations for providers to take care of all the things that needed to be done before listing our house.

Sam Keene Stephens | Buyer

Molly Penny and Katie Penny-Shea are two amazing women! They are experienced, get things done quickly with great recommendation to get your home ready for market and sold quickly. Super service!

Desmond G. Rabinowitz | Buyer

Attention to detail.

John Meder | Seller

Persistent and professional. Went the extra mile.

William M. Merritt | Seller

Know and are part of the community.

Russell Harris | Buyer

Very friendly, locally knowledgeable about the Mercer Island market.

Christopher Blagg | Buyer

Efficient, thoughtful and could not have been more help.

Carol A. Winter | Buyer

Very professional. Good communication. My agent provided a "stager" which was wonderful! You have a great location for MI sellers!

Madeline J. Engel

Molly and Katie Penny are the absolute best. They are so efficient, knowledgeable, trustworthy, and delights to work with. We had a fantastic experience with them, and are happily referring all our friends.